Pick a Pact.

One may preach a covenant of grace more clearly than another. . . . But when they preach a covenant of works for salvation, that is not truth.

Anne Hutchinson at Trial

May 31 2008 12:20 pm | Grace and Read and Speak

5 Responses to “Pick a Pact.”

  1. justin Says:

    my favorite part of the examination:

    hutchinson: what have i said or done?

    winthrop: why for your doings, this you did harbour and countenance those that are parties in this faction that you have heard of.

    hutchinson: that’s a matter of conscience, sir.

    winthrop: your conscience you must keep or it must be kept for you.

    to which i respond: that doesn’t make sense.

  2. Fred Says:

    Justin, I think Winthrop’s last comment means “We’ll tell you what to think and believe.”

  3. Jeri Massi Says:

    Kind of funny to see AH lifted up as a defender of religious liberty. Maybe somebody should go read a few texts of her life. She had her own brand of harm that she did, and she did hurt people. I think her regard for religious liberty, similar to that of the Puritans, was that HER religious liberty should be guaranteed….

  4. cklewis Says:

    Not funny at all, Jeri. Remember who got banished! Not only did Hutchinson make headway for the Quakers, but also she aligned herself with Roger Williams — a man way ahead of his time when it came to fighting theonomy and championing religious freedom (a.k.a. separation of church and state). Historians (both secular and religious from all denominations — even those who call themselves contemporary “puritans”) agree that she was fighting corruption among the powerful, male elites. And the primary documents prove the same.

  5. Molly Says:

    That is SO interesting! Wow. Thanks for the info. I’m going to go find out more.

Leave a Reply